Fleming1995

From emcawiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Fleming1995
BibType ARTICLE
Key Fleming1995
Author(s) David Fleming
Title The Search for an Integrational Account of Language: Roy Harris and Conversation Analysis
Editor(s)
Tag(s) Roy Harris, conversation analysis, integrational linguistics
Publisher
Year 1995
Language
City
Month
Journal Language Sciences
Volume 17
Number 1
Pages 73–98
URL Link
DOI 10.1016/0388-0001(95)00004-F
ISBN
Organization
Institution
School
Type
Edition
Series
Howpublished
Book title
Chapter

Download BibTex

Abstract

The linguist Roy Harris has criticized theories of communication in which language is treated independently of the occasions of its use. Such accounts err, Harris argues, by segregating the linguistic and non-linguistic phenomena of social interaction. In his alternative, however, which he calls ‘integrational’ linguistics, Harris does not specify just how the study of language would be methodologically reconstituted. One model for that reconstitution might be conversation analysis (CA), a program of social research based on the ethnomethodological investigation of ‘language-in-action’. Conversation analysts share with Harris the belief that language is situated, time-bound activity, the study of which should begin with naturally-occurring social behavior, viewed from the perspective of the interactants themselves. In several respects, however, CA departs from ‘integrational’ assumptions, most notably in its exclusive concern for informal conversation, its recurring appeal to formal mechanisms underlying communication, and its reduction of the temporal aspects of social life to the sequential unfolding of events. What may be needed, then, is an approach to the study of language which is more firmly committed to the empirical analysis of naturally-occurring discourse than Harris' linguistics but which avoids the formal and structural abstractions of CA. We might call such an approach an integrational rhetoric.

Notes