Rawls2021

From emcawiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Rawls2021
BibType INCOLLECTION
Key Rawls2021
Author(s) Anne Warfield Rawls
Title Durkheim’s Self-Regulating “Constitutive” Practices: An Unexplored Critical Relevance to Racial Justice, Consensus Thinking, and the COVID-19 Pandemic
Editor(s) Nicola Marcucci
Tag(s) EMCA, Durkheim, Garfinkel, Trust, Racism
Publisher Palgrave Macmillan
Year 2021
Language English
City Cham, Switzerland
Month
Journal
Volume
Number
Pages 227-263
URL Link
DOI
ISBN
Organization
Institution
School
Type
Edition
Series
Howpublished
Book title Durkheim & Critique
Chapter

Download BibTex

Abstract

Durkheim had an ambitious plan to found a new sociology of modernity that would focus on how the conditions for making social facts had changed as societies diversified and modernized. This argument has an unexplored critical relevance for current issues of racial justice that are being exacerbated by a strong residual commitment to older consensus-based ways of making social facts. This paper contrasts two ways of making social facts—culture—in the US, tracing both back to Durkheim’s argument. One makes extensive use of “Dog-whistles” that rely on and maintain a consensus that resists change. The other is grounded in diversity, justice, and equality and promotes change. Because of the degree of reciprocity and cooperation the latter, which Durkheim called self-regulating constitutive practices require, justice and equality—what Garfinkel called “Trust Conditions”—are necessary prerequisites for their successful use. The crisis and division in the US in 2020 involving both anti-science and opposition to racial equality provides empirical evidence supporting Durkheim’s warning that if modern society does not guarantee the justice self-regulating practices required then it will fail.

Notes