Lee2005
| Lee2005 | |
|---|---|
| BibType | ARTICLE |
| Key | Lee2005 |
| Author(s) | Seung-Hee Lee |
| Title | The scales of justice: Balancing neutrality and efficiency in plea-bargaining encounters |
| Editor(s) | |
| Tag(s) | EMCA, Courtroom Interaction, Neutrality, Efficiency, Plea Bargaining |
| Publisher | |
| Year | 2005 |
| Language | |
| City | |
| Month | |
| Journal | Discourse & Society |
| Volume | 16 |
| Number | |
| Pages | 33-54 |
| URL | Link |
| DOI | |
| ISBN | |
| Organization | |
| Institution | |
| School | |
| Type | |
| Edition | |
| Series | |
| Howpublished | |
| Book title | |
| Chapter | |
Abstract
This article examines how the judge balances the normative obligation of neutrality with the bureaucratic demand for efficiency in recorded plea-bargaining encounters. The analysis demonstrates three kinds of judicial conduct by employing the methodology of conversation analysis. First, the judge displays an attitude or an outlook toward the accused or aspects of the case in an embedded manner. Second, the judge facilitates the bargaining process. The judge organizes an opening and a closing of the bargaining encounters, and elicits bargaining activities from the attorneys. Third, the judge moves the bargainers toward resolution. The judge may overtly suggest a bargaining proposal, subtly intervene in the bargaining positions to show approval or disapproval, and press the bargainers to overcome obstacles. The analysis shows that the judge’s conduct influences the bargaining processes and outcomes. The implication of this article is twofold. On the one hand, justice in plea bargaining is implemented in practice and is shaped by the practical ways in which judges manage their role in the interactions. On the other hand, the judge’s role is shaped by the normative obligation of neutrality as reconciled with the practical demands for efficiency. Therefore, the administration of justice in plea bargaining both shapes and is shaped by the judge’s conduct as balanced between neutrality and efficiency.
Alschuler, A. (1976) ‘The Trial Judge’s Role in Plea Bargaining’ , Columbia Law Review 76: 1059-1154 . Google Scholar Alschuler, A. (1979) ‘Plea Bargaining and its History’ , Law and Society Review 13: 211-245 . Google Scholar Atkinson, J.M. (1992) ‘Displaying Neutrality: Formal Aspects of Informal Court Proceedings’ in P. Drew and J. Heritage (eds) Talk at Work: Interaction in Institutional Settings, pp. 199-211. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press . Google Scholar Boyd, E. and Heritage, J. (in press) ‘Taking the Patient’s Personal History: Questioning during Verbal Examination’ in J. Heritage and D. Maynard (eds) Practicing Medicine: Structure and Process in Primary Care Encounters. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press . Clayman, S.E. (1992) ‘Footing in the Achievement of Neutrality: The Case of News-Interview Discourse’ in P. Drew and J. Heritage (eds) Talk at Work: Interaction in Institutional Settings, pp. 163-198. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press . Google Scholar Clayman, S.E. and Heritage, J. (2002) The News Interview: Journalists and Public Figures on the Air. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press . Google Scholar Feeley, M. (1979a) ‘Perspectives on Plea Bargaining’ , Law and Society Review 13: 199-209 . Google Scholar Feeley, M. (1979b) ‘Pleading Guilty in Lower Courts’ , Law and Society Review 13: 461-466 . Google Scholar Feeley, M. (1979c) The Process Is the Punishment. New York: Russell Sage Foundation . Google Scholar Friedman, L.M. (1979) ‘Plea Bargaining in Historical Perspective’ , Law and Society Review 13: 247-259 . Google Scholar Garcia, A. (1995) ‘The Problematics of Representation in Community Mediation Hearings: Implications for Mediation Practice’ , Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare 22(4): 23-46 . Google Scholar Greatbatch, D. and Dingwall, R. (1989) ‘Selective Facilitation: Some Preliminary Observations on a Strategy Used by Divorce Mediators’ , Law and Society Review 23: 613-641 . Google Scholar Hagan, J. and Bernstein, I.N. (1979) ‘The Sentence Bargaining of Upperworld and Underworld Crime in Ten Federal District Courts’ , Law and Society Review 13: 467-478 . Google Scholar Heinz, A.M. and Kerstetter, W.A. (1979) ‘Pretrial Settlement Conference: Evaluation of a Reform in Plea Bargaining’ , Law and Society Review 13: 349-366 . Google Scholar Heritage, J. (1984) Garfinkel and Ethnomethodology. Cambridge: Polity Press . Google Scholar Heritage, J. and Sorjonen, M.-L. (1994) ‘Constituting and Maintaining Activities across Sequences: And-Prefacing as a Feature of Question Design’ , Language in Society 23: 1-29 . Google Scholar Heumann, M. (1978) Plea Bargaining: The Experience of Prosecutors, Judges, and Defense Lawyers. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press . Google Scholar Heumann, M. and Loftin, C. (1979) ‘Mandatory Sentencing and the Abolition of Plea Bargaining: The Michigan Felony Firearm Statute’ , Law and Society Review 13: 393-430 . Google Scholar Jefferson, G. (1979) ‘A Technique for Inviting Laughter and its Subsequent Acceptance/Declination’, in G. Psathas (ed.) Everyday Language: Studies in Ethnomethodology, pp. 79-96. New York: Irvington . Google Scholar Jefferson, G. (1987) ‘Exposed and Embedded Corrections in Conversation’ in G. Button and J.R.E. Lee (eds) Talk and Social Organization, pp. 86-100. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters . Google Scholar Kolb, D. (1981) ‘Roles Mediators Play: State and Federal Practice’ , Industrial Relations 20: 1-17 . Google Scholar Langbein, J.H. (1979) ‘Understanding the Short History of Plea Bargaining’ , Law and Society Review 13: 261-272 . Google Scholar Lindström, A.K.B. (1997) ‘Designing Social Actions: Grammar, Prosody, and Interaction in Swedish Conversation’, unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles. Maynard, D.W. (1982) ‘Aspects of Sequential Organization in Plea Bargaining Discourse’ , Human Studies 5: 319-344 . Google Scholar Maynard, D.W. (1984) Inside Plea Bargaining: The Language of Negotiation. New York: Plenum Press . Google Scholar Maynard, D.W. and Manzo, J.F. (1993) ‘On the Sociology of Justice: Theoretical Notes from an Actual Jury Deliberation’ , Sociological Theory 11: 171-193 . Google Scholar McDonald, W.F. (1979) ‘From Plea Negotiation to Coercive Justice: Notes on the Respecification of a Concept’ , Law and Society Review 13: 385-392 . Google Scholar Mileski, M. (1971) ‘Courtroom Encounters: An Observation Study of a Lower Criminal Court’ , Law and Society Review 5: 473-538 . Google Scholar Morris, N. (1974) The Future of Imprisonment. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press . Google Scholar Robinson, J.D. (1998) ‘Getting Down to Business: Talk, Gaze, and Body Orientation During Openings of Doctor-Patient Consultations’ , Human Communication Research 25: 97-123 . Google Scholar Rosett, A. and Cressey, D.R. (1976) Justice by Consent: Plea Bargains in the American Courthouse. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott . Google Scholar Ryan, J.P. and Alfini, J.J. (1979) ‘Trial Judges’ Participation in Plea Bargaining: An Empirical Perspective’ , Law and Society Review 13: 479-507 . Google Scholar Sacks, H. , Schegloff, E.A. and Jefferson, G. (1974) ‘A Simplest Systematics for the Organization of Turn-Taking for Conversation’ , Language 50: 696-735 . Google Scholar Schegloff, E.A. (1995) ‘Sequence Organization’, unpublished manuscript. Google Scholar Schegloff, E.A. (in press) A Primer in Conversation Analysis: Sequence Organization. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press . Whalen, M.R. and Zimmerman, D.H. (1990) ‘Describing Trouble: Practical Epistemology in Citizen Calls to the Police’ , Language in Society 19: 465-492 . Google Scholar Vol 16, Issue 1, 2005 Table of Contents Article Metrics Related Articles
Cite
Permissions
Share
Download PDF Read the latest issue of Index on Censorship
Notes
